Today is one of those days where the phrase, “no one is ever satisfied,” rings incredibly true. I belong to a couple groups on various social media platforms that are comprised of other teachers and professionals. Over the recent few weeks, I have seen more and more of them openly bashing judges and what they are saying and or not saying on their scoresheets and critiques. To that I say, stop paying people to judge you if you aren’t ready to be judged. As someone who is both a teacher and a judge, I am very offended by these comments and posts that I see. I understand that dance is dance and it should be fun and carefree, but don’t present yourself as a ‘classically trained’ dancer or studio, then get upset when people are giving corrections.
Growing up, we were truly thankful for the corrections given. I would be worried when I wasn’t getting critiques, corrections, or feedback. Even to this day, I am constantly wanting feedback and critique. To be honest, I think I want it more now than ever because I don’t get to take classes on a regular basis. I look at it as a fresh set of eyes that may say something I have never seen because I see these dancers and pieces of choreography every day. I look to my colleagues who are judging my pieces for not only feedback on my dancers, but on my choreography as well. I like the objectivity in the critiques we receive at the end of the weekend.
No judge is ever coming from a malicious place. No one is ever being mean. Most of the time, we don’t even know what studio you are from because we work with studio codes to keep it fair. We start to see trend of training and style, but we never know exactly who is from what studio. So no…competitions are not rigged. They are judged SOLELY based on what you presented in that three minute piece or over the entire weekend. If you don’t like the scores or rankings you received, it is time to take a good, long, hard look at what is happening in class. Sometimes, it is based off of how a student or group of students rehearse. Other times, it’s because the teachers don’t have a finely tuned eye and are not correcting what turns into costly mistakes.
Again, people say it’s about more than just technique and dancers should feel more and think less, etc. But those same people who preach that are up in arms when these ‘dancers’ are poorly representing us in these clothing and fitness ads. It’s those same people who most likely aren’t pleased with the scores they received and take it to social media and just complain and moan about what they didn’t receive. People have complained that judges talk to much. People company that judges don’t talk enough. I understand not talking can be a bit disheartening, and I am guilty of it as well. We have a lot more going on at that table than you think. We are multitasking for hours. Days, even.
I personally give a little more critique to those dancers that are so close to great things. So yes, I will harp on you falling out of that triple. Yes, I will tell you that I think your arabesque could be higher or more behind you. Yes, I will tell you to strengthen and stretch your feet. I will also quickly tell you how to achieve these new goals. I will tell you these things because in the 2 minute and 37 second solo, I saw the amount of potential you have. In that 2 minute and 55 second group piece, I felt your passion. Over the course of the weekend, I saw that you and your fellow dancers love dance just as much as I do.
My job as a judge is to help facilitate growth. To give feedback. And yes…to JUDGE. Do I think we should move to a compulsory rubric of what is required at what age and level? No, I don’t. That takes the artistry out of what we do. We are not cheerleaders. We are not gymnasts. Their artistry is completely different. We are dancers. We are choreographers. I rarely give perfect scores. I can count on one hand, without using all five fingers, that I have ever given a perfect score to a dance or dancer.
I always tell my dancers, different day, different judges could make a completely different outcome. I constantly remind them that it is all based on someone’s opinion. I am also telling them that they need to dance for themselves first, their teachers second and judges third. If I say you did a great job, guess what…? You did a great job. If you are just out to win trophies, go for it. If you are okay with mediocrity and filling your kids with millions of little white lies that they did great, that’s on you. But remember, you are cultivating these young adults who will eventually go on into the real world. If tell a kid she has the most beautiful arabesque you’ve ever seen and she goes out on an audition and is told that her leg is not straight, nor is it behind her and she isn’t using her proper turnout, that’s your fault. And remember that us judges tried to tell you that one day.
XO,
#DanceTchrProbs